Sunday, March 9, 2008

Megan


8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well, I can now say I have read two of the vampire books. I'm not sure if I will continue. I told Chrissy to just tell me the rest of the story. It's not that I hated the books, I just did not feel that I had accomplished something when I was finished. Then I find out that there are at least 3 more books!

My main issue with the story was that teenagers just don't talk like that! It was goofy for me, and I just wanted to slap Bella. She was phony, then there was Edward, gag. The storyline was interesting and had possibilities but I thought the author just got lazy and couldn't finish what she started. I will be interested to hear everyone elses opinions.
Love, Sara

Anonymous said...

I don't want to sound immature about these books since everyone seems to think that they are so phony because I loved them. There is a 4th one coming in the Fall and I can hardly wait!

Now, I know that people don't talk like that in real life and everything was gag-ish, but I like that about the book. I like this book and the series because I know that it could never happen. I also like that it is a quick and easy read. I don't have to struggle to realize what was happening. (I felt that it read a lot like Harry Potter. It was easy to understand and kept me interested.)

Anyways... that is all I have to say about why I like those books. I have actually read these books many times... haha... I know you all are laughing at me now.

meg said...

I saw this review and thought it was perfect! It's a husbands cliffs notes version of the Twilight series:

Edward: I hate Bella.

Bella: I love Edward. Oh his eyes! What should I do? Whine, whine, whine.

Edward: OK, I don't hate you, I just have no self-control (typical guy), oh, and I want to kill you.

Bella: I love Edward. Oh his eyes! What should I do? Whine, whine, whine.

Jacob: I love Bella too, but I want to kill her. And Edward.

Edward: I want to kill Jacob.

Bella: I love Edward and Jacob. Oh their eyes! What should I do? I know, I'll lead both of them on and just whine the entire time.

Edward: Look, I'm shiny!

Jacob: Look, I'm strong!

Bella: Whine, Whine Whine.

I couldn't stop laughing when I read this because I often felt this same way when I read the series. But, like Liz, I loved that it was easy reading that you didn't want to put down and didn't have to think about. I would give it a 9 because, let's be honest, I'm probably going to like it better than the "thinking" books.

Annette said...

So I had some reading time on my hands and thought I would jump ahead and get Twighlight read so that when it was time to read New Moon in a couple of months I would be ready. I'm embarassed to say I couldn't wait until June for New Moon. Before I knew it I was reading the third book. The entire time I was thinking and actually saying outloud, "Oh, brother!" Go figure. I think one of the reasons I liked the books is because they were so easy to read. If there is another reason I'm not quite sure what it is.

The vampire got me and I'm sure I will be reading "The Host" coming soon to homes all over the world.

katetheskate said...

I thought that it was quite dubious of Meg to choose a sequel as her book. That's like getting a wish, and wishing for more wishes! Pretty sneaky, but clever.

I am going to be completely honest here - after reading Twilight, I was NOT looking forward to New Moon (I really didn't feel capable of getting through another vampire baseball game without experiencing an eye-roll induced migraine). I was just hoping that it didn't suck (haha).

Here's the kicker, even though I didn't like Twilight (it wasn't terrible, just sort of redundant - I felt like the same things were being said over and over and over...), I actually got on board for New Moon. I'm not sure what it was, almost as if the author was more comfortable with her characters or something. The story was getting pretty good. That is, until Bella flies off to save Edward in Italy. It lost me after that. What I'm sure was meant to be a "twist", I felt actually interupted a much more interesting situation. Of course I realize that Bella and Edward must be reunited at some point, but the way it was done seemed disjointed from the rest of the book, and left things a little too unresolved. For example, Victoria was played up too much to have so little happen - the mere threat of her didn't feel like enough in the end. Also, the whole Romeo and Juliette thing was a bit much - it felt like sort of a cop-out to parallel that as much as it does. In a series, the individual books have to stand on their own to a point, and I'm not sure that they do.

So, am I going to read Eclipse? Haven't decided yet. Maybe. I'm not sure that I can resist the temptation of finding out which Edward lusts after more, Bella's "blood or her body"...... I think I just threw up a little.

Anonymous said...

Kate, if you read Eclipse it will solve your "unresolved issues" (so to say) about Victoria and what happens to her. It also answers the question of Jacob vs. Edward! Keep reading and find out!

chrissy said...

Definately good for a laugh. I agree with liz, if the book wasnt gagish then it probably would be really really boring. But I still do not understand why people are in love with edward, the guy wears turtle necks and eats bears.... (the eating bears part doesnt bother me as much as the turtle neck does.) My friend just found out that her uncle dated the author of twighlight in highschool, I guess he dumped her before prom cause she was stalker weird. Just a fact I thought that I would throw in there.

Anonymous said...

I just want you all to know that I just finished the last book of this series and the last book "Breaking Dawn" is definitely the best. If anyone wants to know what happens to Bella, Edward, or Jacob and don't want to read the books, let me know and I will be happy to fill you in on the details!