Sunday, March 9, 2008

Marmie


4 comments:

katetheskate said...

I was so excited to read this one again. It was one of my all-time favorites from high school english class. As I was reading, however, I realized that in my mind I had morphed 2-3 novels into this one. I was remembering a mix of this, Cold Sassy Tree, and Growing Up. Completely different.

I couldn't help but recall several of our class discussions about certain themes from this book (OH NO! High School flashbacks ... AAAHHH!). One of these was about the part where the dying immigrant recalls throwing a bride and groom to a looming pack of wolves, and being driven from his home because of it. Brutal and shocking, certainly, but this ties in with another part of the book where Jim kills the snake (ewww...). I think the phrase was "the world doesn't owe anyone a living", or something like that. Interesting concept, I think. I think that it's a way of saying that no one is immune in life.

For some reason, I really like books that cover a large span of time. There's something about knowing what happens later to a character in their life. It's satisfying closure to hear that even though Antonia seems to miss her potential, she wins in the end. It's like when they add those few sentences to the characters at the end of a movie, telling what happens to them in the future ("Billy went on to become..."). I love those.

Overall, I remember liking this book a lot more 10 years ago, but highly recommend it to anyone who hasn't read it yet.

Annette said...

It was interesting to read that Kate thought Antonia won in the end. I thought the complete opposite. Kate, we will have to discuss this! From Antonia and Jim's first introduction I expected a love story, even until the last page! Dang!

I loved this: "All the years that have passed have not dimmed my memory of that first glorious autumn. The new country lay open before me: there were no fences in those days, and I could choose my own way over the grass uplands, trusting the pony to get me home again. Sometimes I followed the sunflower-bordered roads. Fuchs told me that the sunflowers were introduced into that country by the Mormons; that at the time of the persecution, when they left Missouri and struck out into the wilderness to find a place where they could worship God in their own way, the members of the first exploring party, crossing the plains to Utah, scattered sunflower seed as they went. The next summer, when the long trains of wagons came through with all the women and children, they had the sunflower trail to follow." He goes on to say that sunflower-bordered roads always seem to be the roads to freedom.

I'm glad I read this book and thought it was basically centered around fond childhood memories. We all have them and it gives us a little nudge to revisit them in our own mind.

katetheskate said...

That is a great excerpt. Very visual.

I guess what I meant by Antonia "winning" in the end, was that it seemed as though her character was headed somewhere pretty dire. In the end, although it probably wasn't exactly what she had envisioned for herself, her place in the world seemed fitting. It's like she belonged right where she was, living on the land she loved and being as fertile and lively herself as it was.

I originally thought that there would be more of a love story too. In a way there is though, Jim's infatuation with Antonia and the "working" girls is probably more real-to-life than a conventional love story would have been. He was forever affected by her, just as much as if there had been a love affair (maybe even more so).

I love this!

Anonymous said...

As I read "My Antonia" I became very disappointed. Growing up in VA I was not familiar with any prairie like settings and it was really hard for me to visualize the scenery that the whole book was in.

Overall, I felt this book was pretty boring. It focused around one boy who never got married and set his life on the joys of the past. I also got irritated because the book would quickly go from very detailed in one time period to skipping over years of time.

I found that I felt like Antonia did sort of win in the end because she was extremely happy with her children and her husband. I did want her and Jim to get together, but I liked how he found that he loved that he could always love her and the memories that they shared together.