Sunday, March 9, 2008

Kate


6 comments:

Annette said...

In this book Wang Lung believes in the "virtue of hard work and the reward of effort." Buying up as much land as he possibly could, and happiest when he worked it, proved to be his success. Still today, investing in land seems to be a smart thing to do if you have the means.

I loved O-lan for her loyalty and determination. It is O-lan who should be credited for Wang's prosperity and high social status. I kept hoping that Wang would bury the two pearls with her when she died. It was lousy of him not to. Although this book is portrayed as being a man's world --women are only used for pleasure and to bring sons into the world for status -- it seemed curious to me that Wang took so much advice from the women around him.

All in all I thought Wang had a soft heart. He was always aware of and took care of "old fool" when most men would have killed her when she was born. He says he never loved O-lan but I had the impression that he truly did appreciate her and the talents she had to help him prosper. I thought it was an interesting "cycle" of Wang coming from the land and then returning to it in the end.

I liked this book. It was a book that kept my attention.

Anonymous said...

My opinion of Wang Lung slowly diminished throughout this book. I really liked him at first and how humble he was and careful with his money. He actually cared about O-lan and then he got money and he decided to take on another wife and spend money freely. The thing that really irked me about Wang Lung is that he gave O-lan the pearls (even though she was the one that took them to begin with) and then took them back to give to Lotus even though he knew how much they meant to O-lan. I also hoped that he would bury her with the pearls, but he just made it so that Lotus didn't wear them any more.

O-lan was the ultimate working mom. She gave birth to many children all by herself and on most occasions was out in the field helping Wang with the wheat. I also really liked the part where Wang Lung said that once O-lan died that he had never noticed how much O-lan really did for the family. It made me think of the quote, "You never know how lucky you've got it until it's gone."

Although I did not like Wang Lung very much throughout the book, I did like how he respected O-lan and her opinions. He listened to her more often than any other and cared for her even though he did not love her because she was ugly. I truly felt for O-lan when Wang lung heard the small girl tell him that his mom said that Wang Lung did not love her because she was ugly and her feet were too big.

I would hope that even if I was not the prettiest that my husband would learn to love me after all the work that she did for him and their family.

I would give this book a 8 out of 10.

katetheskate said...

I wrote a response to this book just after reading it (which I sent along with it), so the story isn't quite as fresh to me now.

I really enjoyed this book. Even though it's a completely foreign time and place, it's still very relatable. Jealousy, greed, infatuation, stubborness, frailty, loyalty, suffering, helplessness, pride, etc. Some parts made me angry (my inner feminist). Some made me cry (the mother in me). If I had read it earlier in my life, I'm not sure that I would have felt some of these issues as personally as I did. For example, the whole starvation period during the drought was pretty brutal. It actually hurts just to think of having to watch my children suffer like that.

I think that had this story been written by a man, it would have lacked the "completeness" that it has. Though it's told through a male perspective, it has the care and delicate detail that only a woman could deliver, in my opinion. What is very impressive about this book, is it's simplicity. I never felt as though there was too much or too little, in plot or description. It was just a good story, that kept moving.

I can't say that I liked the characters, but I think that is intentional. They seem very human and real to me, believable and complicated. It's very interesting to me that as vital a character O-lan is, there are really only glimpses into the "real" her. You think you've had her figured out, but you haven't at all. I also think that the whole pearl thing was basically a representation of O-lan and Wang Lung's relationship. To him, he gave her the things that were needed for their life together, but not love. He gave that to someone else.

I could probably go on and on about the many issues in this book, but won't. Definitely a great read. I'm glad that I finally got around to it!

Anonymous said...

I loved this book! I don't know why exactly, maybe because of its simplicity. It read kind of like the bible to me, for example "Wang Lung planted the seeds and watered them, and saw that they were good." I don't know if anyone else knows what I mean, but the blunt writing of the story made it kind of sound like the bible to me, and I really enjoyed it.

I never hated Wang Lung throughout the story, on the contrary, I liked him a lot. The inner feminist inside of me was screaming at times, but in order to enjoy this book you have to silence the screaming within you and just take the book at face value and respect it for its time and when it is set. Although he didn't love O-lan, he was a good husband to her. Most other men would abuse their wives and call them names and belittle them and a plethora of other horrible things, but he always respected her and was good to her even though he did not love her.

I liked Wang Lung because he had a soft heart. Even though he lost his temper at times, his heart always conquered his conscience and he usually did the right thing. I remember a passage where his second daughter tries to hide her suffering caused by her feet being bound, and when he asks her why he hasn't seen her cry about it before, she answers him by saying that her mother told her to not cry out loud so that he may hear her because he would feel bad and would want her to take the bindings off of her feet. When I read this I knew that Wang Lung was really a good guy and better than most in his time. He also saves Pear Blossom from his cousin at the end, which I thought was great because I can't imagine a worse thing than having to let a man you fear and despise have his way with you.

Even though he hurt O-lan by taking the pearls away from her and taking on a second wife, these two things were really the only hurtful things he did and I respect him for that. It's a shame though that his good heart didn't rub off onto his sons, who were really doomed from the start because they were raised into money.

I think the most depressing thing about this story was that his entire life Wang Lung had sacrificed everything for his land because he knew that it would be something that no one else could ever take from him, but his obsession with the land doesn't outlive him and his sons plot to sell it as soon as he dies.

One last thing that I really liked about Wang Lung was that even though his first daughter, the "poor fool" suffered from some kind of severe mental handicap and was really just a burden to him, he grew to love her dearly. Even when he is at the end of his life and is basically just waiting to die, he doesn't choose to be with his sons (which he was so proud of when they were born), he chooses to be with his poor fool because she brings him peace and he loves her. As morbid as it may sound, he plots to have her poisoned when he knows that he is about to die because he figures this will be better for her because otherwise no one would take care of her and she would die a much worse death by starving or wandering about the streets. He has this plan for her because he knows that he is the only one who cares for her and he wants to know that he will be with her after he dies. I think that is the best thing he could do really, because he knows that his way is better for her than leaving her to die in a more horrific way. It's just another example of how Wang Lung has a really good heart.

Anonymous said...

This was a hard to put down book for me. Well written books are such a treat no matter the subject, most of the time. Good choice Kate.

The main issue for me with this story, was that even though it wasn't a main emphasis, physical beauty was important. I found it interesting that having a clefpallet or big feet was not acceptable in a wife, but handicapping a little girl by binding her feet so that they did not grow, was a mark of beauty in a woman. To go through life just sitting, being carried on a litter or steadied by someone because your feet could not carry you was elegant. I am sure there are many comparisons to our life now that could be made. We all handicap ourselves one way or another, whether it be physical or emotional. I think Pearl is a brilliant writer. I intend to read more of her books and essays.

When I was in grade school I remember them showing a movie with Ingrid Bergman. It was from a Pearl Buck book about an orphanage, but I cannot remember the name of it. The feet binding was also an issue in that story. Thank goodness most of China has broken with that tradition I hope by now.

I would rate this book a 9

Anonymous said...

I watched the old old movie. The girl who played Olan, won an academy award that year.....she was pretty bad. You would think they could have picked a Chinese person to play Wang Lung, but nooooo they picked some white guy and tried to paint him Chinese. It didn't work. He looked sort of familiar, but I don't know who he was. So if anyone is interested it is out there. Not the best movie, and strayed from the book a little but interesting after you have read the book, if you want to seek it out. I found it on Comcast ON DEMAMD.